Jewelry Store in Oyster Bay, NY
Where Oyster Bay Gets Engaged

Jewelry Store in Oyster Bay, NY

We are your trusted store in Oyster Bay, NY. Shop our collection of engagement rings.

Smith Jewelers - Top Rated Jewelry Store In Oyster Bay, NY

Established in 1940, Smith Jewelers in Oyster Bay is family-owned and specializes in fine jewelry sales, custom designs and restoration in the New York and Long Island areas. We offer an exquisite selection of engagement rings, as well as, custom wedding jewelry and a variety of options to suit any style, occasion, or taste.​

Our commitment to elegance and artistry is made evident through our stunning collections. We continue to foster relationships with artisans from around the country while maintaining our established connections to discerning local talent.​

Our attention to detail has earned us a reputation for excellence.

Jewelry Store in Oyster Bay, NY
Jewelry Store in Oyster Bay, NY
Learn More
Jewelry Store in Oyster Bay, NY


Custom Designs

Work closely with our Master Jeweler to create a one-of-a-kind piece to your specification.

Learn More

Follow Us on Instagram


Customer Reviews

Local gem I've been going to since childhood with my Mom. Beautiful selection, personal service, repairs by people you can trust.

Connie DeSalvo

Always a pleasure. Friendly people, great place to shop.


Great personal service with expert repairs - exceptional knowledge of settings and gemstones - My one and jeweler I trust.

Anne Biernacki

Smith Jewelers

11 E Main Street
Oyster Bay, NY 11771

Tuesday - Saturday
10:30am -5pm

Get directions